I Wasn't Supposed to Read That...

My first real introduction to books came in the fourth grade, in the very small library of the private Christian school I attended. I don’t remember how many shelves there were, but in my memory there weren’t many. It hardly mattered. To me, that little room was enormous.
There was nothing particularly illicit hiding on those shelves. This was, after all, a Christian school. The Chronicles of Narnia became one of my first go-to choices and, without my knowing it at the time, my introduction to fantasy. In the classroom, literature included books like The Pilgrim’s Progress and Hinds’ Feet on High Places. The boundaries may have been fairly narrow, but inside them I discovered something I hadn’t expected: I loved stories.
At home, reading was a much narrower proposition. My mother didn’t believe in fiction. The Bible was acceptable, of course, along with The Two Babylons, a book I’m fairly certain no fourth grader has ever stayed up past bedtime desperate to finish. Books written by Christian authors might pass inspection. Anything else was questionable.
Unfortunately for my mother, I had discovered the library.
And I wanted all of it.
I wanted stories about people who didn’t live like we did, places I had never seen, adventures I would never be allowed to have and ideas I hadn’t been introduced to before. Once I realized all of that could be found between two covers, there was really no going back.
So I learned to read somewhat illicitly.
Books that wouldn’t meet approval came home quietly and stayed out of sight. Reading became something I did whenever and wherever I could, sometimes with the added challenge of making sure no one knew exactly what I was reading.
For a child being taught that the world was something to be wary of, books offered a rather serious loophole.
Then I went to public school.
Compared with that little private-school library, the public-school library seemed enormous. There were so many books—and not all of them had to teach me something, improve my character, or contain a Christian allegory. There were simply stories. Shelves and shelves of them.
In seventh grade, I discovered science fiction.
Fantasy had already shown me that a wardrobe could open into another world. Science fiction showed me that the world—or worlds—could be almost anything. The possibilities were amazing and sometimes frightening. Strange planets, futures that had gone terribly wrong, technology that might save humanity or destroy it. I could travel through space, forward in time, or into some imagined future that seemed just plausible enough to be unsettling.
I devoured it.
Then eighth grade brought me back to private school and another discovery: mysteries.
Trixie Belden, the Hardy Boys, Nancy Drew—I tore through them. There was always another clue, another secret, another person who wasn’t quite what they seemed. I loved trying to figure things out before the characters did, although I’m sure I was nowhere near as good at it as I thought I was.
By then, the pattern was pretty well established. Give me a genre and I would happily disappear into it.
As I got older, naturally, my literary interests became much more sophisticated.
Enter the Bosom Heavers.
There seemed to be an endless supply of lost or imperiled maidens being rescued by surly lords, brooding strangers and, when necessary, pirates. There were windswept moors, castles, ships, misunderstandings and a great deal of smoldering. Somehow, despite all the danger and questionable circumstances, everyone’s honor remained remarkably intact.
I read those voraciously, too.
But somewhere along the way, real people began competing with imaginary ones for my attention. I discovered biographies and autobiographies—particularly the stories of men and women who had overcome terrible odds, endured extraordinary circumstances and, often, found or accepted Christ somewhere along the way.
Those books were different.
Fantasy had taken me to other worlds. Science fiction had shown me worlds that might be. Mysteries gave me puzzles to solve, and romance provided a reliable supply of surly lords and pirates.
Biographies opened up the real world.
Here were people who had actually lived through war, poverty, persecution, loss, failure, adventure and circumstances completely outside anything I knew. Their lives weren’t neatly contained within the boundaries of my own experience. Through them, the world became bigger again—not imaginary this time, but real.
And I wanted to know more.
And then came Uncle John.
Uncle John became my provider of what could politely be called “inappropriate” reading material—which, naturally, made it considerably more interesting.
At fifteen, he handed me Alien.
This was definitely not Narnia.
There were no noble quests, no helpful lions and very little concern for anyone’s honor. There was, however, a creature loose on a spaceship with a particularly unpleasant method of introducing itself.
I was horrified.
I was fascinated.
I made it halfway through.
Then my mother discovered the book and –poor Uncle John.
I never got to find out how it ended—at least, not then. But by that point, taking away the book was a little like closing the barn door after the horse had left. I already knew those books existed.
I may not have gotten to finish Alien, but I had read enough to know I wanted more.
Being deprived of the second half of Alien certainly didn’t cure me. Stephen King, Dean Koontz and a whole collection of horror writers soon joined my reading pile, introducing me to homicidal clowns, possessed cars, rabid dogs and all manner of things waiting in dark corners. But horror didn’t replace anything. I still wanted Narnia, distant planets, clever detectives, surly lords, pirates and remarkable real people. Apparently, when it came to books, I had no type. I just wanted more.
These days, my bookshelves are probably a fairly accurate reflection of where all that indiscriminate reading led. Murder mysteries have claimed the most territory, alongside a growing collection of controversial books—the sort that make me want to know why someone thinks I shouldn’t read them. There are treasured first and second editions of Agatha Christie, classics I’ve collected over the years, shelves devoted to wine, and many, many cookbooks, with Julia Child and Escoffier well represented. It’s an eclectic collection, but then, I’ve never seen much reason for a bookshelf—or its owner—to stay in one lane.

It all started with a very small school library and a very limited selection of approved reading. More than fifty years and an unreasonable number of books later, I’m still incapable of walking past a bookstore, library sale or interesting title without wondering if I have room for just one more. I don’t, of course.
That has never stopped me.


