top of page
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

A Dinner Most Poe-culiar: An Evening at Shields Tavern

Writer: Cynthia
Cynthia
Oct 31
6 min read

There are few things more fitting for an October evening than candlelight, a historic tavern, and the promise of an intimate dinner with Edgar Allan Poe. Add the atmospheric surroundings of Colonial Williamsburg, and the stage seemed perfectly set for an evening of mystery, macabre storytelling, and perhaps a little literary madness.

At least, that was the promise.

Dinner with Edgar Allan Poe, held at Shields Tavern in Colonial Williamsburg, was advertised as an unforgettable evening spent in the company of one of America's most celebrated literary figures. Guests were invited to enjoy a three-course dinner while Poe entertained with haunting tales, conversation, and selections from his works. The description even emphasized, "This is not a lecture. It is an evening spent in the company of Poe."

For $130 per person in General Admission, we expected an intimate, well-organized evening of dining and entertainment.

Unfortunately, the confusion began before we ever reached our table.

We were among the first guests to arrive—the third group of couples, in fact—yet at check-in there was no explanation of the seating arrangements, no indication that tables were unassigned, and no guidance about how guests would be accommodated. Once it became apparent that seating was essentially first-come, first-served, we found ourselves having to be unusually assertive simply to secure a table for our party of four.

Once inside, we located a table, only to be informed that we were in the VIP dining room and would have to move. By then, the General Admission room was already filling, leaving us scrambling to find four seats together.

As it turned out, VIP guests had been seated approximately thirty minutes before General Admission guests, and Poe had already begun his performance. To reach our designated dining room, we—and the other arriving guests—had to walk directly in front of him while he was speaking.

Not exactly the atmospheric entrance one imagines for an evening of nineteenth-century literary entertainment.

The arrangement was disruptive to the performance, awkward for arriving guests, and seemingly avoidable with a little planning and communication.

Having finally found our seats, we were immediately served dinner. And here we encountered another curious interpretation of the advertised experience.

The promised three-course meal consisted of a single piece of fried chicken, a handful of green beans, mashed potatoes, and a basket of rolls with butter. The food itself was decent, but unless the bread basket has recently been elevated to the status of an independent course, I'm still trying to locate the third.

Dessert arrived in a parfait glass filled with whipped cream and topped with a square of cinnamon doughnut. An unusual presentation, certainly, though hardly the sort of finale one might anticipate from a special-event dinner at this price point.

Our waitstaff were initially very pleasant and engaging. Beverages were offered, and our party settled on glasses of wine, eager for the evening to begin. Despite the confusion upon arrival and the rather modest dinner, we were still looking forward to the entertainment. After all, the principal attraction wasn't the fried chicken. It was Edgar Allan Poe.

And here, thankfully, the evening had something genuinely worthwhile to offer.

The actor portraying Poe was excellent. He brought the character to life with an engaging, convincing performance that we thoroughly enjoyed. His portrayal was easily the highlight of the evening, and he deserves considerable credit for maintaining his professionalism under circumstances that did him few favors.

Unfortunately, the event's organization seemed determined to make his job as difficult as possible.

Rather than the intimate evening described in the advertisement, General Admission guests discovered that Poe would be dividing his time between the VIP and General Admission rooms. While different ticket levels are perfectly understandable, the format and its implications for the entertainment should have been made clear beforehand.

At one point, approximately an hour passed between his appearances in our room, with no explanation of when he would return or how the evening was intended to proceed.

And wait we did.

Other couples eventually left, and we came very close to joining them.

To make matters worse, somewhere during that lengthy absence, most of the waitstaff seemed to disappear as well.

By then, we had finished our first glasses of wine and would have welcomed another. Unfortunately, there was no one around to ask. The servers who had been so pleasant and engaging earlier in the evening were suddenly nowhere to be found.

Toward the end of our hour-long wait, a woman came through offering water. We asked whether additional drinks were still available, and she assured us they were before going to find someone who could assist. To her credit, someone returned shortly afterward and took our orders.

Looking around the room, we noticed that some tables had open bottles of wine sitting on them. Whether those bottles had been purchased separately or provided as part of another arrangement, we couldn't say. What we could say was that no one had offered us a refill or the opportunity to order a bottle until we specifically asked for assistance.

It was another example of the evening's inconsistent communication and service. The staff we encountered were personable and willing to help, but the overall coordination left much to be desired.

Eventually, Poe returned.

Even he seemed to need a moment to recall exactly where he'd left off. Hardly surprising after an hour spent entertaining another audience. To his credit, he handled the transition with the professionalism of a seasoned performer and continued to deliver an enjoyable portrayal.

Unfortunately, just as we were settling back into the performance, another distraction presented itself.

A separate event had begun upstairs, directly above our dining room. The noise from the gathering overhead was substantial enough to interfere with Poe's performance below. After waiting an hour for his return, we now found ourselves trying to enjoy his storytelling over the sounds of another event taking place above us.

One might reasonably expect a venue hosting an intimate theatrical dinner to consider whether simultaneous events would interfere with one another. Apparently, that possibility had not been adequately addressed.

Storytelling depends on rhythm, atmosphere, and the connection between performer and audience. An hour-long interruption does little to preserve any of those things, and competing noise from another event certainly doesn't help. By the time Poe returned, some of the audience's enthusiasm had understandably faded, and the momentum he had worked to establish had been lost.

None of this was the fault of the actor. Quite the opposite. His performance deserved a better setting and a more thoughtfully organized presentation. The audience deserved the opportunity to enjoy his talents without lengthy, unexplained interruptions and distracting noise from overhead.

Perhaps most surprising was the impression that the organizers seemed entirely satisfied with how the evening had unfolded. There was no apparent acknowledgment of the confusion, the lengthy interruptions, or the other difficulties guests had experienced. It wasn't until one member of our party expressed her disappointment with the organization of the event as she was leaving that there appeared to be any indication that the evening had been less than successful.

Whether the organizers were genuinely unaware of the problems or simply had a different perspective on the evening, it's difficult to say. But from our side of the table, the shortcomings were hard to miss.

And that's what makes this experience particularly frustrating.

Williamsburg has an audience hungry for interesting, engaging entertainment. Residents are willing to venture out, support local events, and pay for quality experiences. An evening featuring Edgar Allan Poe in a historic tavern is precisely the sort of creative programming that should appeal to both residents and visitors.

The concept was excellent. The setting was appropriate. The performer was talented. The audience was willing.

What was missing was the planning and coordination necessary to bring those elements together.

For $130 per person, guests should reasonably expect a well-managed experience from arrival through the conclusion of the evening. At the very least, they should know where they're supposed to sit, how the entertainment will be presented, and what their ticket actually includes. A meal advertised as three courses should deliver three recognizable courses, and guests shouldn't have to hunt down someone to order a second glass of wine.

This isn't a complaint about the existence of VIP seating, the quality of the actor, or the friendliness of the staff. It is a criticism of an event that promised an immersive evening and delivered a fragmented one.

Would we recommend the actor portraying Edgar Allan Poe? Absolutely. He was talented, engaging, and a pleasure to watch.

Would we recommend this particular dining experience as it was organized? Unfortunately, no.

And that is a shame, because Williamsburg needs more events like this—not fewer. But good ideas deserve good execution, particularly when guests are willing to invest their time and money in them.

Poe understood better than most the importance of atmosphere, anticipation, and timing. The organizers of this evening could have taken a lesson from him.

We came expecting an evening in the company of Edgar Allan Poe. Instead, we spent a surprising amount of it wondering where he'd gone.

Would we attend another evening with Poe? Gladly. Would we pay $130 to spend another hour wondering where he'd gone?

Quoth the Raven, 'Nevermore.'

bottom of page